文献中正交试验的常见问题分析和解决方法

    Common Mistakes Made in Some Literatures When Performing Orthogonal Experiments and Solutions

    • 摘要: 目的 提高正交试验的质量和实用性。方法 对文献报道的正交试验进行总结分析。结果 部分正交试验存在的问题和后果是:无空白列导致夸大随机效应;无理由忽略交互作用导致混杂现象;手工计算导致方差分析错误;最优工艺不考虑成本因素导致无谓增加生产成本。结论 正交试验应该留有空白列;否定交互作用的存在应该有实验或文献的支持;应该使用专业统计软件分析数据以确保结果的准确性;工艺考察应包括成本-效益评估。

       

      Abstract: OBJECTIVE To improve the quality and utility of orthogonal experiments. METHODS The orthogonal experiments in published literatures were reviewed. RESULTS The common mistakes made in some literatures and outcomes were: orthogonal design or orthogonal table without blank column, resulting in inflating the random effect; baselessly ignoring the interactions, resulting in confounding bias; wrong results of analysis of variance (ANOVA) because of manual calculation; the selection of optimal process without considering cost-effectiveness, incurring cost increase of manufacturing. CONCLUSION Blank column of orthogonal table should be reserved for error estimated; the interactions could be ignored only when their existence are denied in relevant experiments and literatures; the data of orthogonal experiments should be analyzed using statistical software to make sure the accuracy of the results, and the cost-effectiveness should be considered in the selection of optimal process.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回